Six Sigma and Value Stream Mapping (VSM) are both methodologies aimed at improving processes and increasing efficiency, but they differ in their focus and techniques. However, they can complement each other when applied together in a lean or continuous improvement initiative.
We’ve been helping large enterprises with their value streams for years – you can see some of our clients here. This article will help you understand a little bit about how Six Sigma and value stream mapping work together. And if you’d like a hand with your value stream mapping, ask for a meeting here.
What is Six Sigma?
Six Sigma is a data-driven methodology aimed at reducing defects and variability in a process to improve quality. It focuses on process improvement by eliminating sources of defects or errors, ensuring that the process operates within acceptable limits of variation.
Six Sigma uses the DMAIC framework (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, Control) to systematically improve processes by identifying root causes of problems and implementing solutions based on data analysis.
The ultimate goal is to achieve near-perfection in process performance (a defect rate of fewer than 3.4 defects per million opportunities).
What is Value Stream Mapping (VSM)?
VSM is a lean tool used to map the flow of materials and information throughout a process. It visually represents the steps in a process, identifying value-added and non-value-added activities with the goal of reducing waste, inefficiencies, and bottlenecks.
The goal of VSM is to optimize the entire process by streamlining activities and improving overall flow, typically using lean principles like waste reduction, continuous improvement, and just-in-time production.
How Six Sigma and VSM Relate:
Complementary Focus
Six Sigma primarily focuses on quality and variation. It is used to solve problems that cause defects or process variation. By analyzing data, it finds the root causes of inefficiencies and works toward eliminating defects to achieve consistent output.
VSM primarily focuses on process flow and efficiency by eliminating non-value-added activities (waste) and optimizing the flow of materials and information.
When used together, VSM provides a high-level overview of the entire process and identifies waste, while Six Sigma focuses on solving specific problems that cause inefficiencies or defects within the value stream.
VSM in the Define and Measure Stages of Six Sigma
In the Define and Measure stages of the Six Sigma DMAIC framework, VSM can be very useful. VSM can be used to map the current process, providing a clear view of where problems are occurring and where waste exists.
By mapping out the current state, you can better define the scope of your Six Sigma project and measure key metrics like cycle time, lead time, and inventory, which will be used later in the analysis.
Six Sigma for Problem Solving
After VSM has identified inefficiencies in a process, Six Sigma can be used to dig deeper into the root causes of those inefficiencies. For example, if VSM shows that a particular process step takes longer than it should, Six Sigma tools like root cause analysis (e.g., fishbone diagrams or 5 Whys) can be used to understand the reasons for that delay.
Six Sigma’s data-driven approach helps to measure variation and ensure that changes made based on VSM analysis are sustainable and lead to defect reduction.
Improvement and Control Phases
In the Improve phase of Six Sigma, you can design future state processes using insights from the VSM exercise, ensuring that improvements align with lean principles (e.g., reducing waste, improving flow).
And in the Control phase, Six Sigma helps ensure that the improvements made through VSM and Six Sigma are sustained over time by monitoring performance metrics and using tools like control charts.
Waste Reduction
Both Six Sigma and VSM focus on waste reduction, but from different angles. Six Sigma reduces waste by minimizing defects and variations, while VSM eliminates waste by streamlining the entire process and removing non-value-added activities.
Six Sigma can be applied to the waste identified in the VSM to ensure that the root causes of the inefficiencies are understood and addressed.
Example of VSM and Six Sigma in Action
Imagine a manufacturing process where VSM is used to map the current flow of materials and information. The VSM exercise reveals that there are long delays in the assembly phase. Using Six Sigma, you can perform a detailed analysis of the assembly process to understand what is causing those delays, such as machine downtime, poor workflow layout, or inconsistencies in part quality. By applying Six Sigma tools, you can fix these issues and then redesign the process to flow more smoothly, as indicated in your VSM future state map.
While Six Sigma and Value Stream Mapping are distinct tools, they work well together. VSM gives a high-level overview of the entire value stream, while Six Sigma focuses on improving specific aspects of quality and reducing process variation. By using both, companies can streamline their processes (VSM) and ensure those processes are consistent and produce high-quality results (Six Sigma). This combination is often referred to as Lean Six Sigma, a powerful methodology for continuous improvement.
We've gotten good at this! Book a meeting if you'd like to learn more. We eat, sleep and breathe value stream maps.